Jersey Hustle Pizzeria

Why go: A family-owned New Jersey-style pizzeria on Hwy 66 with a full Italian kitchen, gluten-free crust, and a Philly cheesesteak that gives the pizza a genuine run for most-ordered.

About Jersey Hustle Pizzeria

Jersey Hustle Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated restaurant founded by Brent and Jennifer Bown, bringing New Jersey-style pizza to Sevier County across four locations. The Sevierville outpost on Winfield Dunn Parkway is the county’s easternmost location, positioned close to the I-40 interchange and a natural first stop for visitors heading into the mountains.

The menu centers on New Jersey-style pizza, with specialty pies that go well beyond the standard topping combinations. Named options include the Surf City, Capone, Heart Attack, Boardwalk, Classic Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, and a Philly Cheesesteak Pizza for guests who cannot settle on one or the other. A Sicilian cut offers the thick, square-pan format, and a gluten-free pie is on the menu for guests who need it.

Beyond pizza, the kitchen covers the full Italian-American range. Chicken parmigiana, penne alla vodka, chicken picatta, baked ziti, lasagna, and fettuccine alfredo handle the pasta side. Philly cheesesteaks, Italian hoagies, calzones, and stromboli fill out the sandwich and baked options, with wings and appetizers rounding out the menu. A kids section covers spaghetti, fettuccine alfredo, and chicken tenders.

Getting to Jersey Hustle Pizzeria

The Sevierville location sits at 750 Winfield Dunn Pkwy, Suite 130, Sevierville, TN 37876, along Highway 66. From I-40, take Exit 407 south onto Winfield Dunn Parkway; the restaurant is a few miles south on the right. Parking is available on site, and the Hwy 66 location places it between the I-40 interchange and the Tanger Outlet Center, making it a practical stop whether you’re heading into the mountains or on your way back out.

Why Choose Jersey Hustle Pizzeria

A few things separate Jersey Hustle from the generic pizza options along the Smokies corridor:

• Authentic NJ-style recipe. The Bown family built the menu around the pizza they brought from New Jersey, not a regional approximation of it. The specialty pie names and flavor profiles reflect that lineage.
• Philly cheesesteak as a destination item. Guest feedback on the cheesesteak with fries is consistently strong enough to treat it as a reason to visit on its own, separate from anything on the pizza side of the menu.
• Four-location family operation. Brent and Jennifer Bown own and operate all four Jersey Hustle locations in Sevier County. That matters for consistency: the recipes and standards travel across locations because the same family controls all of them.
• Gluten-free crust available. The gluten-free pie is on the menu and available through online ordering, which is not a standard feature at every pizza spot along the Hwy 66 and Parkway corridor.
• Delivery works for cabin stays. DoorDash delivery is active for the Sevierville location, and call-in delivery is available directly through the restaurant, which makes it a realistic option for guests in nearby cabins or condos.

Menu Favorites

The menu covers the full New Jersey Italian range. A few items worth ordering:

• Philly Cheesesteak with Fries. One of the most consistently mentioned items in guest feedback; the bread quality and fresh toppings get specific attention in reviews.
• Sicilian. A thick, square-pan pizza with a different crust texture and weight than the standard round pies. A solid choice when the group wants something more substantial to share.
• Surf City. A signature specialty pie that showcases the Jersey Hustle approach to pizza building, outside the expected topping combinations most casual spots default to.
• Chicken Parmigiana. Served as an entree with pasta; portions run on the generous side and the preparation stays true to the Italian-American classic.
• Penne Alla Vodka. A reliable pasta option in regular rotation, and a solid pick for anyone at the table who would rather skip the pizza that evening.
• Calzone. Baked and folded with fillings sealed inside; a satisfying alternative to a slice for guests who prefer their ingredients closed rather than open-faced.

What to Expect

Jersey Hustle is a casual, family-friendly counter-service setup. A few things worth knowing before you go:

• Order at the counter. There is no table-side ordering. It is a quick, no-frills setup that keeps the pace moving and the focus on the food.
• Wait times stretch on busy weekends. Peak vacation periods mean longer waits. Calling ahead with a pickup order before you arrive is an option and can help cut the time.
• Credit cards accepted. Visa, American Express, and other major cards are accepted at the counter.
• Online ordering is available. The restaurant’s direct ordering system handles pickup orders at jerseyhustlepizzeria.com. DoorDash also handles delivery, and the restaurant offers call-in delivery for local stays.

Nearby Restaurants in Sevierville

• Buddy’s Bar-B-Q. A Tennessee BBQ staple with a Sevierville location on Winfield Dunn Pkwy, serving smoked meats, combination plates, and loaded sides a short distance from Jersey Hustle.
• Aubrey’s. A polished casual dining spot on Dolly Parton Pkwy with a broad menu and consistent table service, a good option when the group wants a sit-down meal with choices beyond pizza.
• GRAZE Burgers. A downtown Sevierville burger spot focused on fresh ingredients and creative builds, worth the short drive for a different kind of casual meal.
• Flapjack’s Pancake Cabin. A breakfast destination on the Parkway drawing early crowds with pancakes, French toast, and a full morning menu that justifies the wait on busy days.
• Pinchy’s Lobster and Raw Bar. A downtown Sevierville seafood spot serving lobster rolls and raw bar selections that stand well apart from the pizza-and-BBQ rotation typical of the area.

Explore More

My Smoky Mountain Guide Sevierville is a great resource for finding things to do and places to eat.

• Sevierville Food and Beverage Guide. Browse restaurants, coffee shops, distilleries, and dessert stops in Sevierville, organized by category.
• Sevierville Attractions. From outlet shopping to attractions and entertainment venues, find out what else is happening along the Parkway and beyond.
• Sevierville Outdoor Adventure. Hiking, paddling, ziplines, and more outdoor options in Sevierville.