Bizzarro Pasta & New York Pizza

Homemade dough, authentic Italian recipes, and generous portions make Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza a go-to on Soco Road for real New York style pizza, classic pasta dishes, calzones, and a family-friendly atmosphere with beer and wine.

About Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza

Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria located at 1560 Soco Road in Maggie Valley. The restaurant brings authentic New York style pizza and classic Italian dishes to Soco Road, with every pizza made from homemade dough and every order prepared fresh. The owner, who previously operated a Bizzarro location in Florida, brought the same recipes and commitment to quality when relocating to Maggie Valley, and the restaurant has quickly become one of the most popular dining spots in the valley.

The menu covers a full range of Italian favorites. New York style pizza is the headliner, with a crust that reviewers describe as the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, topped with a sauce that draws comparisons to what you would find in Rome. Beyond pizza, the menu includes pasta dishes like eggplant parmigiana, lasagna, and chicken piccata, along with calzones, stromboli, garlic knots, and antipasto salads. Gluten-free crust, cauliflower crust, and gluten-free pasta are available for guests with dietary needs. A kids menu with pasta, pizza, and chicken tenders makes it easy for families.

The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, with generous portions, reasonable prices, and friendly servers who are happy to accommodate special requests. Beer and wine are available, and the restaurant offers curbside pickup and delivery through DoorDash for guests who prefer to eat in their cabin or hotel room.

Getting to Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza

Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza is located at 1560 Soco Road, along the main commercial corridor through Maggie Valley. The restaurant is easy to find on the primary highway through town and offers on-site parking. Its location on Soco Road puts it within easy reach of Maggie Valley’s popular attractions, shops, and lodging options.

Why Choose Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza

Bizzarro stands out on Soco Road for doing one thing exceptionally well: authentic New York style pizza with homemade dough, prepared fresh for every order. The crust is the foundation, and reviewers consistently call it some of the best pizza they have had in the Smoky Mountains. The sauce, the toppings, and the overall quality set it apart from chain pizza and frozen-dough alternatives. If you have been craving real pizza on your mountain vacation, this is where to find it.

The Italian menu beyond pizza is equally solid. The eggplant parmigiana, lasagna, and chicken piccata are all prepared with care, and the calzones and stromboli offer hearty, satisfying alternatives. Portions are generous, prices are reasonable, and the staff makes you feel welcome the moment you walk in. The gluten-free and cauliflower crust options are a thoughtful touch for guests with dietary restrictions, and the kids menu ensures the whole family can enjoy the meal. With curbside pickup and DoorDash delivery, Bizzarro also makes it easy to bring the food back to your cabin for a relaxed evening in.

Menu Favorites

• New York Style Pizza. Homemade dough with a crust that is crunchy and chewy, topped with sauce reviewers compare to what you would find in Rome.
• Eggplant Parmigiana. A classic Italian dish prepared with care, one of the most praised entrees on the menu.
• Lasagna. Perfectly layered and cooked, a hearty comfort food favorite.
• Chicken Piccata. A well-prepared Italian classic served with your choice of pasta, salad or soup, and garlic bread.
• Calzones. Huge, stuffed, and served with garlic knots and a zesty dipping sauce.
• Garlic Knots. A popular side and starter that reviewers consistently praise.
• Veggie Pizza. A fresh, well-topped option for vegetarian guests.

What to Expect

• A casual, family-friendly atmosphere with friendly servers and a welcoming vibe.
• Authentic New York style pizza made from homemade dough, prepared fresh for every order.
• A full Italian menu with pasta dishes, calzones, stromboli, salads, and appetizers.
• Generous portions at reasonable prices.
• Gluten-free crust, cauliflower crust, and gluten-free pasta available.
• Beer and wine available.
• Curbside pickup and delivery through DoorDash.
• Delivery closes 30 minutes before pickup.

Nearby Restaurants in Maggie Valley

• Guayabitos Mexican Restaurant. A family-owned Mexican restaurant on Soco Road with scratch-made sauces, fajitas, burritos, and a full bar with margaritas.
• Maggie Valley Sandwich Shop. A local favorite for fresh deli sandwiches, soups, and quick lunches along Soco Road.
• Legends Sports Bar and Grill. A lively sports bar on Soco Road with hand-pattied burgers, jumbo wings, live music, and 24 beers on tap.
• Teague’s Grocery and Cafe. A Soco Road staple since 1965 with a deli cafe serving hand-patted burgers, scratch-made biscuits, and hearty breakfast plates.

Explore More

Bizzarro Pasta and New York Pizza is your gateway to a full Maggie Valley experience. After your meal, explore the area’s many attractions and outdoor activities.

• Things to Do in Maggie Valley
• Attractions in Maggie Valley
• Outdoor Adventure
• Food and Beverage Guide